Actually it makes perfect sense, if you know what's actually going on.
It makes no sense, if you know what's actually going on. My secret knowledge that I'm not going to tell anyone makes my argument more right than your secret knowledge that you're not going to tell anyone!
You'll forgive me if I'm rather skeptical of your arguments, especially since you have a tendency to base your estimations of "internal instability" in Asylon based purely on... well, nothing.