Also if while I was torturing your character I cut his hand off, then you RP using that hand, your powergaming.
Actually no. By the RP rules of BM you are actually power gaming by cutting off the hand of a character without the consent of the player that controls the character. You might not like the rules, or agree with them but those are the rules for this game. Else we would have Judges that role-play cutting off all the limbs of everyone that arrives in their dungeon during a war then arguing said nobles can no longer lead troops into battle due to their injuries. If you where meant to be able to inflict those sort of injuries there would be a mechanic to allow it. Remember this is not a straight RP game, it is a RP/Strategy blend.
