Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - JDodger

Pages: 1 ... 37 38 [39] 40 41
571
Far East Island / Re: The Empire
« on: October 09, 2015, 07:02:50 AM »
hi vita <3

im actually more inclined to believe that you just misinterpreted jonn's intent, as taylins letters and your posts here indicate. i/jonn never tried to play the grand manipulator, never had any ulterior motives, and never offered to spy on cathay. jonn was simply in cathay to try to convince bofeng to make peace because at that point sorraine looked done and coralynth was going to be next.

corresponding with taylin was like talking to a crazy person with delusions of persecution. whole lot of wild and inaccurate assumptions and insults.

572
BM General Discussion / Re: game freeze
« on: October 08, 2015, 05:33:20 PM »
any general estimate of when we might expect it?

573
BM General Discussion / game freeze
« on: October 08, 2015, 04:53:08 PM »
Is this happening?

574
Far East Island / Re: The Empire
« on: October 06, 2015, 08:51:52 AM »
Also I dont consider this thread toxic just spirited disagreement. I certainly dont feel offended or desire to offend anyone.

575
Far East Island / Re: The Empire
« on: October 06, 2015, 08:50:41 AM »
Jonn never offered to spy on cathay.

Not surprised about Bofeng.

Pretty sure no one ever besieged Colasan while GDD had it. At least not intentionally. Cathay sure didnt.

576
Far East Island / Re: The Empire
« on: October 02, 2015, 03:24:30 AM »
I'm aware that Indirik is a veteran and Taylin has been active since the early days of OW. I am attempting to help distinguish between the bofeng and post-bofeng parts of the war, which indirik's post has all jumbled together.

the breakup of morek was a great move for dwilight, congrats. not sure what that has to do with the subject at hand.

ill stop being condescending when i stop reading lame excuses. deal?

577
Far East Island / Re: The Empire
« on: October 01, 2015, 09:24:00 PM »
Also since Jonn has been running the war for Cathay we have lost only one battle, that being the aforementioned failed attack on Lenamaziel when everyone was inactive. Since then we have won every time. If that's not beating you badly I'm curious to hear your definition.

578
Far East Island / Re: The Empire
« on: October 01, 2015, 09:10:50 PM »
History lesson:

Coralynth and Sorraine tried to gangbang OW. Cathay entered the war to defend their ally, a move everyone knew they would make. This would have been a good war if others hadn't gotten involved. Velax's decision to enter the war was what made that war so bad.

The only attacks on Colasan were during the Bofeng era. Since he left no attack has been made on Colasan by anyone.

Some of you may recall that Jonn was initially in Cathay for the purpose of brokering peace between Cathay and Sorraine (what?  :o ) and only got directly involved when Claudio betrayed Cathay with the slaughter in Colasan (declaring war on his former ally when their military was already in a level 5 walled region stocked to the gills with troops)

GDD was able to capture Lenamaziel right after because they and Sorraine were able to jump on the region while Cathay's military was destroyed, a huge portion of their nobles were wounded, and then Bofeng quit, leaving Cathay without a leader.

What most of you don't know is that Jonn was so fed up with the war against Sorraine (a war in which he didn't fight at all) that he was going to defect to Coralynth during the tourney in Enlod. I figured if Bofeng wasnt going to listen to me I may as well join the underdogs directly. Then claudio betrayed cathay during the tourney, bofeng quit, and suddenly it was a completely different war. So Jonn left his homeland behind once again and returned to Cathay to do the honorable thing and keep the realm alive.

I hear so much whining about inactives in this thread and it makes me laugh. What you guys seem to forget is that Cathay after Bofeng left was like a dead realm for weeks. No one thought we had any hope of survival. Nobles were leaving left and right. The only active characters were Jonn and Nairii. Our first attack on Lenamaziel failed badly because we got only four nobles to march on time with about three days' notice and constant reminders. It was a suicide attack anyway, hoping to use our better refit times to launch a second attack before GDD and Sorraine could recover, but even that failed.

The point is that we didn't give up. The "roving raiders" you refer to were our best break. We destroyed them despite about half our force being inactive, because instead of whining about how the game has changed I just adapted our strategy to deal with it. Once we beat the GDD raiders it breathed new life into Cathay. Suddenly it looked like we could win, at least battles if not the war, and a lot more people got active.

The point is it is the responsibility of the leaders of each realm to inspire their nobles, and if they fail to do so defeat follows. It's not the map, it's not militia, not player density, not any of that crap. It's a question of quality leadership and strategy. The Nairii/Jonn/Optimus triumvirate has succeeded using the same materials--players and ingame resources-- that Bofeng and your realms failed with. We even succeeded with a lesser amount of those materials.

There's a lot of things I could say here but you guys have been playing long enough that I shouldn't have to teach you how to lead wars. Please feel free to keep making excuses. I am not saying any of this to insult you but I have grown tired of the constant excuse making in BM especially on FEI. The difference in our abilities to take responsibility for our actions is the reason for the differing levels of success of our realms. As leaders you always had the ability to make things better for your realms but you failed to do so. Take it as a lesson.

579
Far East Island / Re: The Empire
« on: October 01, 2015, 09:04:45 AM »
Lol ok.

First off I didnt address your lame excuse of "its so hard to coordinate three realms" because... it's a lame excuse. You had three on one odds and completely botched it. That's not some inherent handicap of being multiple realms, that's just poor leadership and strategy.

Spinning is the exact word for what you're doing, and yes, my argument is correct and yours is wrong. Arcaea is not screwing Cathay in any way.

I'm not whining, I'm winning.

Your realms are now smaller because we beat you a few times and your realmmates quit in droves. When I talk about odds being against Cathay I am talking about the past, what part of that are you missing out on? At one point GDD and Sorraine each had more nobles than Cathay, either realm should have been capable of doing some serious damage on its own.

My entire point is that no one came on the forums crying WHEN the odds WERE (notice the use of past tense) against Cathay, most of our nobles just hung tough and followed their leaders. Their leaders took responsibility for bringing them through hard times and lo and behold we came out on top without any help. Arcaea is late to the party and we will see how much leftover cake they want before they leave.

In contrast, your side completely crumbled as soon as we put up any resistance and its most vocal leader is showing us why - excuses on excuses instead of knuckling up and taking responsibility.

I have no idea why PoZ is on that list, we are at peace with them. "Paper tiger" is a term for something that looks threatening but isn't. PoZ doesn't look threatening to Cathay.

Sorraine is not a threat at ten nobles and no functional allies.

To sum up: you lost when you should have won. The odds are against you now because that's how things go when you lose over and over to a smaller enemy and people get tired of it and leave. You should not whine about it after the fact.

rip

580
Far East Island / Re: The Empire
« on: October 01, 2015, 06:28:47 AM »
I thought someone meant that arcaea had a new ruler...

gotcha. they were referring to viridiana.

@gundammerc if youre going to throw insults at least read my post. "was" is a past tense verb. at the peak of your alliance's noble count it was 36 vs 12 nobles, exactly three to one. even before myern existed it was 30 on 12 when sorraine and GDD each had 15. Previous to Arcaea's entrance to the war, or maybe previous to your most recent embarrassment in Lenamaziel, your alliance had 24 or 26, cant recall exactly, so you still had twice our number.

Now you're down to 18 and if you do the math, we were surviving against (and beating in skirmishes) Sorraine and GDD as two realms with nearly double that noble count, and beating you guys badly as three realms with 2.5x that noble count. So no, Arcaea isn't screwing us over, because it doesn't matter how many realms you are, but a good try at spinning the situation.

581
the requirement of no unit would make this solution unpalatable to the vast majority of nobles to take part in, which will render it useless from the beginning.

i dont see why a noble couldnt simply hunt monsters themselves WITH a unit, or seek items or talk to sages. actually i think that would be a.fun way to alleviate boredom in a peaceful realm.

all in all though i dont see the treatment of advs as anything game breaking. it is frankly annoying especially in the realm you are referring to, but mainly because of certain personalities involved and not necessarily game mechanics. but when you consider the size of that realm and its busy military, the advs are frankly essential - and this would, in real life, cause them to enjoy an elevated status in society.

the rank system in the royal rangers guild though - total bs. "Noble ranger" rank for commoners should never have existed.

582
Far East Island / Re: The Empire
« on: October 01, 2015, 01:19:56 AM »
i wondered when the crying would start. didnt have to wait long, i guess.

it was noticeably absent when cathay was outnumbered three to one, had no relevant allies and no food.

maybe thats why weve been winning anyway.

buck up guys, every time arcaea enters a war someone starts crying that fei is dead. yet it keeps going and i would posit is more interesting now than it has been in a while. figure something out.

@indirik ruler doesnt vacate as easily as other council positions (maybe depending on govt type, cant speak for republics) so taylin is still queen.

583
BM General Discussion / Re: Server Move - check in
« on: September 30, 2015, 02:48:15 AM »
looks just like the old forum

584
Far East Island / Re: The Empire
« on: September 08, 2015, 09:46:31 PM »
@indirik yeah, for the sake of brevity i condensed all the various plans dustole/claudio presented. it was around his second or third permutation that I realized he was just riffing on bs and probably spinning all sorts of tales to others as well.

@eirikr this is exactly why jonn urged nairii and optimus to get in touch with foreign rulers to let them know that someone somewhere was totally against claudio's plan and willing to stand against him.

and yes, while I was adamantly against his plan ic and ooc I have to give credit where it's due, the whole thing was a near-masterful act of political trickery.

585
Far East Island / Re: The Empire
« on: September 08, 2015, 01:54:23 AM »
@gundammerc: the plan he discussed with me was to ally every realm except ow and coralynth and then declare war on each of them until they swore allegiance to claudio. he was quite sure in both ic and ooc communication that he would have the support of arcaea, sorraine, zonasa and gdd, and alternately made promises and threats according to this assumption to get myself and others on board with his plan. when he failed to gain my/jonn's support he announced to myself and others that cathay would be "destroyed", not just beaten into submission, but ended as a realm.

 what is cynical is to assume that this plan would be somehow fun for the players of the realms being ganged up on. losing wars can be fun but impossible ones are not. had his plan succeeded it would have resulted in less nobles and less realms for the already depopulated far east, a point which i made several times in the course of trying to negotiate a more universally palatable version of his plan.

in fact it would not have been fun for hardly anyone, unless easy mode gangbang wars are your sort of thing. i would like to think of most bm players as appreciating the challenge of a good even war. which it looks like we are about to have, so that's fun.

Pages: 1 ... 37 38 [39] 40 41