It would allow for infils, former advies and players who trained swordsmanship to be dickish. It has its benefits and its problems. Not really the solution I'd give.
By infils, if you mean they can't duel, I never accept that as an in-game excuse.
As for others being dickish because of good swordsmanship skills, I guess that's just unfortunately a bit of real life. However, my experience has been that those players aren't usually the dicks, it is usually newer players or guys who have been around forever but hardly ever trained.
