Firstly, let's leave all the cussing and negative perception of the accused (not just from the complainant) out of the courtroom section of the forum.
Understanding that OOC I am already fully aware of the truth and am making this request from a purely IC perspective [...]
Under other circumstances you would probably need to state how exactly you are aware. In this case it is not needed for me as torture reports (as with anything IG) is naturally translated to make sense IG and its existence would make requests for it perfectly natural as well.
SMA - many things IG would not be SMA - the game mechanics itself. Magic owls, undead, monsters - even daimons
- even the torture reports that provide exact words. No one could realistically produce that even under torture. But we have to work with it and make it fit.
Meta-gaming - simply unavoidable. Basic test, knowing when 'turn' changes and planning around it. Let's not say that it's fair because everyone knows about it because then everything would need to be revealed so that no one would have an advantaged but some things are intentionally kept secret for you to find out.
Exploitation of bugs - unless the torture report is NOT working as it is then there is no exploitation.
So you admit that you sometimes ask for scribe notes for the 100% OOC certainty that it gives you, the player. But you're here prosecuting a magistrates case against another player claiming that's what he did?
This seems pertinent.
