The Order declared the CoS evil after Selene, in response to a purely secular war, declared she would burn all Order holy sites in Masahakon, the Order's most holy city, and pledged to kill every man, woman and child of the Order in Masahakon.
Your fault for talking NS into a joint war with C'thonia and then stabbing it in the back immediately after hostilities were declared. If an oathbreaker and general liar like Thain can be made head of the Order of the Elders then that's living proof that the Order is evil :p
