Full Complaint Text:
A character in my realm(Heroot- Atamarra) was banned yesterday. The reason for the ban was not following orders and replying messages.
The judge right after giving these reasons sent an OOC, explaining how the player was convicted for being part of the Saxon Clan.Â
The OOC message showed that the ban had more OOC reasons for happening than IC, also with the recent DNS problem, it is not possible to say if the user was actually ignoring orders (no further proof were presented that he were)
After a brief OOC and PM discussion, I am presenting the case here.
Bellow are the initial messages with the ban and OOC reasons.
Noble banned!  (1 day, 7 hours ago)
message to all nobles of Heorot
Sir Thorstein Brynjulvson Galle, Law Father of Heorot, Knight of Makar has declared Aethelwulf Lurdigala, Count of Shiverwood an enemy of the realm and will issue a ban on him shortly. He has given the following reason:
Due to their breach of our laws, particularily as pertains to feudal duties, non-cooperation and their refusal to explain their actions over a considerable amount of time, the Law Thing has voted to ban the Lurdigala family from our realm.
Noble asked to leave!  (1 day, 7 hours ago)
message to all nobles of Heorot
Sir Thorstein Brynjulvson Galle, Law Father of Heorot, Knight of Makar has openly asked Siegfried Lurdigala, Count of Uforth to leave the realm within three days, or a ban will be spoken on him. He has given the following reason:
Due to their breach of our laws, particularily as pertains to feudal duties, non-cooperation and their refusal to explain their actions over a considerable amount of time, the Law Thing has voted to ban the Lurdigala family from our realm.
Out-of-Character from Thorstein Brynjulvson Galle  (1 day, 5 hours ago)
Message sent to everyone in your realm (28 recipients)
Regarding the ban on the Lurdigala family:
It is often difficult to balance in context and out of context knowledge when dealing with characters in this game. The Lurdigala family has been hit with several bans and Game Master intervention for what is termed clanning in the so-called Saxon clan. The modus operandi is that of a swarm of locusts. They will gold hoard in the realms they use to gather gold, then transfer the gold to realms they do control. They do not cooperate with others and add little to their realms, and whathever realm ends up run by them inevitably gets destroyed. As we have seen with locked accounts in Heorot and BoM there are also issues of multiing involved with them, although there is no evidence as far as I know of Lurdigala being a multi.
I have seen some of the actions this player has been punished for. For a few weeks my char Thorwald was member of Averoth, a very poor realm in Northern Dwilight with an absolutely massive army for its 4 poor regions, with 20 players that could move as one in the last couple of hours before the tick. The only way to actually have a fighting unit there was through family wealth. I was truly impressed with their military abilities. But it was very, very quiet. Eerily so. I decided to leave after the General did not give his usual orders, and his marshall stepped in. While there would be no stragglers when the General ordered a move, now roughly half of the army stayed behind. I paused my character a few days later.
The Saxons, including Aethelwulf Lurdigala had a Magistrate ruling against them for their actions in Fontan:
"A dev investigation has revealed evidence of a clan in the form of uncanny gold distribution patterns, a history of one group of players acting in unbroken unity across numerous realms and continents, that same group practicing IG clan-actions such as clan-only armies, collective migration/character creation, and possibly clan-restrictions on title access. Given that these practices constitute a violation of the Social Contract, namely, a commitment to valuing fair play more than victory or power, and to playing Battlemaster as you would a board game with friends, the Magistrates find that there is a clan active related to Aurvandil and Fontan which is substantively diminishing the game experience of Battlemaster for other players. As the specific complaint was raised in regards to players with characters in Aurvandil also having characters in Fontan, only those characters and players shall be directly punished. However, the Magistrates have also found this clan to be active, in varying degrees and in varying ways, historically, in Arcachon, Averoth, and Thulsoma. While all players are welcome to play Battlemaster with friends, we also expect all players to invest in a constructi