I think we might have a bit diffrent view what kind of change Atamara needs
I'm pretty sure, that wiping out realms totally, or making them lose bad, real bad... will only lead people to leave island(voluntarily or forced)... which sucks these days. Darka has a lot nobles, but many realms lack nobles and could definately have more.
Example if Darka would be wiped out or KK forced to leave island and Darka would be left with few badlands at north... I would prolly leave island with my other char too, and i can guess that many other old Darkans would too, and some even quit whole game.
Red Span wipeout, many fun players left, i didnt feel bad back then... but now i do. Abington wiped out, many old players left... then i felt a bit bad, we run out of enemy
I guess i'm getting old, cause i dont want to lose any players from Atamara, or the game... IC it would be hilarious to force council of CE & Tara to leave island and force them to split out all duchies to dozen midget realms... but as a player... it would suck... except the midget realms would amuse me greatly as player too....