There should be permadeath on Dwilight. I second that notion - but I doubt it'll ever happen. That said, I wouldn't mind realm power positions going permadeath. As for people complaining that people would stop being council members or bankers because of it... Why? It makes sense for a council member to stay behind and not go suicide charging the enemy ranks. If they want to play recklessly like that, they should be put in a position of danger. If they don't want to die, they should stay far from the front lines, or even stay back at home.