It is an intriguing suggestion, but I don't think that I would enjoy the extra workload. I know that I'm not the only mod with limited time to spare.
Also, I would not want to enshrine the vitriol and insults in a Hall of Fame.
As far as rules lawyers go, I find that nothing discourages them fatser than a quick smackdown and refusal to debate the rules. Providing examples is like throwing gasoline on a fire.
