If you think all of that, then why do you act IC as you do?
Because it's the course of action my character would take. I know you don't understand this, though. That's OK.
You think Atanamir is what he is because he accepted to read from a publically available script?
Absolutely.
*Every* ruler on EC is playing a predetermined part that is 100% predictable. If you discount the migration of Eponllyn due to the ice (which was an OOC curveball that no one could have predicted, and didn't really change much anyway), then the situation as it stands now was 100% predictable as far back as 8 or 9 months, if not longer. Everyone knew that this is where we would end up. Atanamir's actions are perfectly predictable. We expected everything that has been played against us, and from exactly the people it came from. Fallangard was the final one to sign off on the script, but even that happened a good three or more months ago. I'm not exempting myself, even Eponllyn's part is playing out according to script. Given our place in the situation, there are just no other viable paths to follow.
EC has devolved into two camps, north vs south. No one on either side is willing to even entertain the possibility of switching sides, or standing up and staying independent.
What EC needs is a free-for-all system like war islands. Everyone at war with each other and no allies
A balkanization of the island would be great. Perhaps as the player density goes up, it may happen. The low player count is what got us to where we are.