The question is whether because Shadovar was a colony of Pain en Luries the claims revert back to Luria or whether they pass to D'Hara as the legitimate successor state. So while it's understandable where the current Lurian claim comes from, it's a far stretch from being the only valid interpretation.
I never said that Luria's claim to the isles is uncontested. The only thing I am trying to assert is that Luria has a legitimate means to make such a claim. If D'Hara wants to contest it, through much the same argument that Luria would make against them, they can, but essentially it comes down to being able to assert one's claim through war against the other. Luria has never been forced to formally cede that claim to another realm, because Luria has never lost a war to a non-lurian entity.
So only war can really settle the question.
