Yeah, but the system changed now. My Public Info is still locked at yes for playing more then 2 characters though, so not entirely sure how it works now (Not that I want to make my info private, but still). Shooting in the dark, but perhaps it won't let you play your third character without making your info public once it's unlocked? I wouldn't know, honestly, and be good to get checked. It might just as well have no effect any more.
