Author Topic: Punishing Players for Not Moving within Half A Turn  (Read 46035 times)

Draco Tanos

  • Mighty Duke
  • ****
  • Posts: 1128
    • View Profile
    • Nova Roma
@DracoTanos:So it is OK because Fal'cie continued to post after the order was given? And if Fal'cie had *not* posted after that, then it is not OK. Which means that whether or not Allomere violated the IR depends not on what Allomere does, but on what Fal'cie does. So Allomere can't know if he's going to violate the IR when he posts, because he couldn't know if Fal'cie is going to respond? All Fal'cie has to do to get Allomere busted on an IR violation is to shut up and play possum.

How does that make any sense at all?

Whether or not you violate the IR depends absolutely 100% on the actions you take, and not the actions anyone may take, or not take, as a result.
So by YOUR logical fallacies, no realm can ever punish anyone for not following orders, no matter how much they are writing to anyone.  Congratulations.  Now knights don't have to follow the orders of the feudal hierarchy.