No, they hadn't. I'll post the relevant sections of the battle here:
Excalibur's Warriors (5) break through the frontlines!
Gilded Knights of Colasan (6) break through the frontlines!
Jade Spears (19) stay behind their camp fortifications.
Victoria Draconis (11) break through the frontlines!
Cathayan Royal Guard (2) break through the frontlines!
Merlin's Warriors (
break through the frontlines!
Dragon Shields (3), White Cloaks (12), Dragon Soldiers (4) and Attlel's Halberdiers (1) advance towards the enemy.
Close Combat (Center Line):
1 Cathay banners are visible in the melee.
Lancers of Green (7) score 288 hits on Ortedail Halberdiers (20).
Ortedail Halberdiers (20) score 107 hits on Merlin's Warriors (
.
Ortedail Halberdiers (20) score 80 hits on Excalibur's Warriors (5).
Ortedail Halberdiers (20) score 124 hits on Cathayan Royal Guard (2).
Ortedail Halberdiers (20) score 105 hits on Gilded Knights of Colasan (6).
Ortedail Halberdiers (20) score 62 hits on Victoria Draconis (11).
Ortedail Halberdiers (20) score 46 hits on Lancers of Green (7).
Total close combat hits suffered: Attackers: 524, Defenders: 288
Close Combat (Defender Line 1):
7 Ohnar West banners are visible in the melee.
6 Kindara banners are visible in the melee.
16 Cathay banners are visible in the melee.
Excalibur's Warriors (5) score 168 hits on Jade Spears (19).
Excalibur's Warriors (5) score 243 hits on Ortedail Halberdiers (20).
Gilded Knights of Colasan (6) score 417 hits on Ortedail Halberdiers (20).
Jade Spears (19) score 136 hits on Excalibur's Warriors (5).
Jade Spears (19) score 122 hits on Dragon Shields (3).
Jade Spears (19) score 193 hits on Attlel's Halberdiers (1).
Jade Spears (19) score 219 hits on Dragon Soldiers (4).
Victoria Draconis (11) score 306 hits on Ortedail Halberdiers (20).
Cathayan Royal Guard (2) score 202 hits on Bleiddiaid (16).
Cathayan Royal Guard (2) score 419 hits on Ortedail Halberdiers (20).
Merlin's Warriors (
score 590 hits on Ortedail Halberdiers (20).
Dragon Shields (3) score 317 hits on Jade Spears (19).
White Cloaks (12) score 472 hits on Bleiddiaid (16).
Dragon Soldiers (4) score 446 hits on Jade Spears (19).
Attlel's Halberdiers (1) score 379 hits on Jade Spears (19).
Bleiddiaid (16) score 286 hits on Cathayan Royal Guard (2).
Bleiddiaid (16) score 169 hits on White Cloaks (12).
Total close combat hits suffered: Attackers: 1125, Defenders: 3959
Those listed as breaking through are in Defender Line 1, but are still hitting and being hit by the unit in the Centre Line, the Ortedail Halberdiers.
