.... so as I said, you've just assumed something to be true on next to no basis whatsoever....
Norrel provided you with two quotes of yours, in which the first you outright declared that there are no elections for the ruler's position, while the second highlighted a fervent OOC perspective that granted the first an obvious source of creation. Rebutting with the same statement "you reckon it could be, on the basis of sure why not" does absolutely nothing to disprove Norrel's claims or the things you've said. Stating that they're not true because they're assumptions is an equally crap argument.
Moreover, stating "Aurvandil doesn't doubt elections at all" is utterly pointless and a petty deviation from the primary point. Norrel isn't arguing whether or not Aurvandil "doubts" elections: in all fairness, no one cares. Norrel is arguing that you're possibly tying passionate OOC beliefs to your character and realm, in a fashion that many people obviously disapprove of.
Perhaps providing better arguments than "No, you're wrong, hence you're assuming things and doing it because why not" or "Those two concrete examples aren't proof, hence they're assumptions and obviously stated because why not" will go far as to shed a clearer light on the differences between you, Mendicant, and latter's decisions.
Edit: clearer for better, and to remove accusations of violations of the game rules, as they were not intended in that fashion.