To Dante's point about discussing potential violations in the game—
What is the point of an adjudicating body like the Magistrates or Titans if not to resolve those very questions? I can envision a scenario in which a potential violation was committed, and through discussion in the realm, an incorrect explanation/defense was given that defused the situation. Why is that a problem? Because it denies someone their only recourse, and it wrongly educates other players about the rules. It's hard enough to convince people of a rule for which everyone seems to understand the basis. It's a nightmare when there's years of misinformation around it.
