As far as losing history and culture etc. being a concern, and Dwilight being brought up.
Compared to the other islands, you would lose less from closing Dwilight than the other islands. Dwi has only been around for a couple years, compared to some of the others which have been around upwards of 10 years.
Dwilight is unique in this case because it was released long after any of the other islands.
I would rather we not close an island, but it's another factor to consider.
Unfortunately, this doesn't take into account the fact that all of the newer players (such as myself) came after Dwilight was created, and know nothing but Dwilight-era Battlemaster. Shutting down Dwilight would basically be closing down my only fun character. The newer players are the people we are trying to retain, since the older players have stayed with Battlemaster through various huge changes (like the sinking of the War Islands), and so would be more likely to bear through it.
