Ok, a couple things:
My original post was about the 1 character restriction on Dwilight. I was wondering if people wouldn't mind that restriction if they could play on every island (which I wish I could do.)
I've been playing since January, both of my nobles are Lords (I aggressively pursued a Lordship as soon as one was open to me.) I've accumulated 88 honor and 35 prestige, but I only have 3 fame. I am very active and play every day, so I don't see how I could've accumulated fame any faster.
Especially since Battlemaster is short of players it seems especially counterintuitive to artificially prevent people that would like to participate on more islands from doing so.