I thought the proposal was to eliminate one island, not to only leave three. Just saying.
Like Tom says, this is entirely unofficial.
If I asked for only one island, I think we would get a lot of "Dwilight" responses, which wouldn't be as useful as knowing which two, or which three, islands are the most loved. 64% of players voted for Dwilight as one of their three islands. Now, I don't know if Dwilight was #1, #2, or #3 on their list, but knowing that 2/3rds of the players (who voted) want to keep it is a pretty strong indicator. 55% voted for FEI, and only 12% voted for the Colonies. AT, BE, and EC are basically tied, which I find interesting.
In a couple of weeks I can start another poll where keeping Dwilight and FEI as taken for granted as being safe, and people have to choose to keep 1 of the four remaining islands, assuming we don't have any major changes in the numbers.
And Tom wants to keep EC, so maybe I can drop that from the running, leaving AT,BE, and the Colonies.
Then the numbers may get especially interesting.
But, I wanted to have an open poll for now.