I think 'gameplay' as a header is a bit misleading. Something more specific like "In-Game Rumor" or "Propaganda" or something similar that conveys that it is information directly from game events but in now way is necessary information for casual players.
That makes it sound completely meta-gamey, which I thought was what we were trying to avoid. Sounds like Tom is more interested in clearly establishing the forum as a pure OOC venue. Better that it be "Island Discussion" or "Game Discussion."