If something like this is done, and I'm not saying it should be done, then there needs to be some serious thought put into the description that accompanies the feature. It *must* be rated from a player perspective, and not related to the fortunes of your particular character. It's whether the *player* is having fun playing a character in the realm, and should be completely unrelated to that particular character's fortunes or status. We shouldn't be seeing things like players rating the realm as bad because they are losing a war, or because their character got banned.