That is one reason I suggested the Titans/Magistrate reform should just be the original report and the magistrate verdict. Have those listed publicly (preferably in a link from the report page or otherwise integrated into the game, though the wiki would also be a fine spot). There can be a forum, with tight moderation, discussing cases, much like the Q&A forum now.
Makes a lot of sense, it is rare that magistrates require lengthy discussion from community to actually make a decision. More often the result is bickering rather then illuminating debate.