Main Menu

News:

Please be aware of the Forum Rules of Conduct.

Ways to improve Dukes

Started by pcw27, July 17, 2016, 02:29:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

pcw27

I saw it suggested in another thread that we make this a thread as well. Inactive Dukes has been a complaint for a very long time now. Ideally they should be a major source of conflict and intrigue. In my other thread I suggested some ways to make dukes more interesting within existing mechanics so this will focus on new ones.

One which has come up is allowing the King to levy specific tax rates on individual dukes. I'm all for this.

My new suggestion, add Dukes to the protest feature. Maybe only for their vassals but maybe for the whole realm. Duke is a high ranking position and should be open to scrutiny.

Zakilevo

Just no. Dukes should be untouchable. They need to be powerful to give more weight to the position.

What I think should be changed is 'Royal Dukes'. If you become a duke you should lose 'Royal' status. It is almost impossible to remove these people.

Vita`

Quote from: pcw27 on July 17, 2016, 02:29:29 AM
One which has come up is allowing the King to levy specific tax rates on individual dukes. I'm all for this.
This has been approved for a long time, as well as for a duke upon individual lords. Just no one has bothered to implement it.

QuoteMy new suggestion, add Dukes to the protest feature.
This is a TODO that's a decade old. For members of the duchy of their respective duke.

Vita`

Quote from: Zakky on July 17, 2016, 02:38:01 AM
Just no. Dukes should be untouchable. They need to be powerful to give more weight to the position.

What I think should be changed is 'Royal Dukes'. If you become a duke you should lose 'Royal' status. It is almost impossible to remove these people.
No, dukes are too untouchable. The protest mechanic is a reasonable limit on them. A royal duke can be protested out of the duchy, if not the royal status.

Zakilevo

Quote from: Vita on July 17, 2016, 04:12:53 AM
No, dukes are too untouchable. The protest mechanic is a reasonable limit on them. A royal duke can be protested out of the duchy, if not the royal status.

I would have agreed if we had a lot of players but with so few players, 1 or 2 people can just protest a duke out.

Gabanus family

Quote from: Vita on July 17, 2016, 04:12:53 AM
No, dukes are too untouchable. The protest mechanic is a reasonable limit on them. A royal duke can be protested out of the duchy, if not the royal status.

I agree with Zakky, this just puts extra abuse on the system. The special taxes are perfect and I agree even with removing the royal status as well. I've always been an action of more intrique with Dukes (as I think my actions have shown as well), but I disagree 100% with protesting Dukes out as well. The same with protesting Lords out, that should not be done. If the above two are implemented, that should give enough fire to 'fight' Dukes to begin with now.

And I say this not because I fear losing my ducal positions, because I only have 1 left and he would never be protested out as he's very loved within his own realm. I'm saying this because I genuinly feel this would ruin the game to quite a certain extend, especially for smaller realms.
New account active chars:
Garas: First Oligarch - Goriad: Astrum - Goriad II: Obia'Syela

JDodger

you guys are once again looking for code solutions to people problems, but i do agree that at this point there should be mechanics to remove dukes from power.

my personal suggestion is to give rulers the ability to strip dukes of their title, but make it take time and give the duke a couple days' warning to give them the opportunity to secede or defect their duchy. if they are really inactive and unpopular the region lords will defect back to the original realm, if the ruler miscalculated he may have a real problem on his hands...
Quote from: GundamMerc on October 01, 2015, 08:28:47 PMBy the way, would love to see you coordinate three realms without having an OOC teamspeak with everyone on it.

Gabanus family

Quote from: JDodger on July 17, 2016, 06:17:01 PM
you guys are once again looking for code solutions to people problems, but i do agree that at this point there should be mechanics to remove dukes from power.

my personal suggestion is to give rulers the ability to strip dukes of their title, but make it take time and give the duke a couple days' warning to give them the opportunity to secede or defect their duchy. if they are really inactive and unpopular the region lords will defect back to the original realm, if the ruler miscalculated he may have a real problem on his hands...

Isn't that already an option with banning him (except the royal thing)?
New account active chars:
Garas: First Oligarch - Goriad: Astrum - Goriad II: Obia'Syela

GundamMerc

I personally would like to see protests. If your duke is inactive, you can just get rid of him.

JDodger

i believe if you get banned you cant secede, removing much of the possible intrigue that could result.

judges are a lot weaker than dukes in most cases, and often its a situation where the only issue with the char is their laziness in their position. no one wants to ban people for inactivity especially someone who must have, at some point, been a useful and liked member of the realm.  we see how often stagnant dukes get banned, its not really done at all.

dukes losing royal status makes no sense as most if not all rulers in a feudal system were dukes as well. however royal status preventing bans makes no sense to me at all, how many rulers throughout history lost their thrones and got to hang around causing problems for the new ruler?

and in case anyone thought "but the ruler can exile them" ... exile is a completely useless and suicidal feature, clicking upon which will allow your rival full ability to troll you in a way unparalleled in its savagery.

i cant stand protests at all, from concept to execution. rebellions should be made more even instead of having such a silly and unrealistic feature. for other council positions you should have to petition the ruler to strip them of their titles, or get them assassinated. protests are an ultimate lowest common denominator, low risk, cowardly feature.
Quote from: GundamMerc on October 01, 2015, 08:28:47 PMBy the way, would love to see you coordinate three realms without having an OOC teamspeak with everyone on it.

Zakilevo

Exile is completely useless. It is a horrible feature that serves no purpose.

Gabanus family

I'm pretty sure a Duke can secceed if he's banned.

Also if the inactive Duke is such a problem, you can get rid of him by banning him. That it's never done has more to do with the player base than with any coding I think. And an inactive Duke often doesn't provide funding to a war etc, so that would be enough reason to ban him if you want. If you ruler/judge are unwilling to do so, perhaps rebel in stead.

I think many of the issues here are player based, not mechannically based. Protesting Dukes just breeds exploits though and I will restate my extreme dislike towards this option, despite my agreement that we should all try to make things more lively, there are better ways than adding protesting though.
New account active chars:
Garas: First Oligarch - Goriad: Astrum - Goriad II: Obia'Syela

JDodger

i think there are better ways to handle a player not living up to the expectation of their position than banning them. in a lot of cases these are players who were once highly valuable to their realm who now simply dont have the time or desire or whatever to play as much. there should be options, just like for council positions, to remove the duke title without kicking them out of the realm.
Quote from: GundamMerc on October 01, 2015, 08:28:47 PMBy the way, would love to see you coordinate three realms without having an OOC teamspeak with everyone on it.

Anaris

Quote from: JDodger on July 17, 2016, 07:39:53 PM
i believe if you get banned you cant secede, removing much of the possible intrigue that could result.

Completely false. Banning a Duke when he's in his Duchy is about the most dangerous thing you can do, because he can either secede or change allegiance before the ban goes into effect.
Timothy Collett

"The only thing you can't trade for your heart's desire...is your heart." "You are what you do.  Choose again, and change." "One of these days, someone's gonna plug you, and you're going to die saying, 'What did I say? What did I say?'"  ~ Miles Naismith Vorkosigan

JDodger

i stand corrected. now that i think of it i was confusing bans with switching allegiance during a to
Quote from: GundamMerc on October 01, 2015, 08:28:47 PMBy the way, would love to see you coordinate three realms without having an OOC teamspeak with everyone on it.