We can start one with: If we are going to sink one continent, which one would be?
I'd rather see we get more players instead but since that doesn't seem to be happening I guess I'd say Colonies or Atamara.
Colonies because, as the poll also states, it seems to be the least popular continent by far. But,
and it is a big but, I don't think sinking the colonies would help the other islands much. There are too few players there and also a different breed of player.
On the other hand, Atamara is not an easy choice at all but it is a large one and with it gone the other continents sure could get a big boost.
Why not Beluaterra? I don't know. Not as big as Atamara these days and I personally like it better. But closing islands always comes down a lot to taste.
Closing i.e Far East has the same problem as closing colonies. I'd say there are too few players there to really make that big difference.