Okay Sailors, here's what I think has happened. On this boat we appear to have two separate groups out to murder everyone else: Mutineers and Daimon Worshippers. If I had to guess, I'd say the Mutineers got the Captain, as he was only stabbed, rather than having his heart cut out like Telrunya. They want to kill us as well as each other. For whatever reason, the groups have to hunt on alternate nights.
The first night, the Mutineers got lucky and murdered Cren, the Daimon Worshipper. The second night the Daimon Worshippers also got lucky and murdered Telrunya, the Mutineer. Meanwhile we Sailors have been running around with no clue, killing our own.
Tonight the Mutineers will hunt again and kill one of us. Given that I've perhaps made myself a target now, I wouldn't mind some Guardian Angel support. Please.